Education during COVID-19: Is E-learning a good alternative?
COVID-19 has disrupted education system and learning environment in almost all the countries. It has exposed our lack of crisis preparedness and the fragility of our global education system.
Most of the colleges, universities and schools are closed in many countries to prevent the spread of virus. According to a UNESCO report, 1.6 billion children across 191 countries have been disturbed by the temporary closure of educational institutions. In case of Nepal schools, colleges, and universities have been closed since the government imposed countrywide lockdown that started from March 2020 and is still prevalent in some form. Since schools and universities have remained closed, it has adversely affected students.
Addressing the current pandemic situation, the Government of Nepal has also launched its first governmental E-learning portal as an open library for Nepali students, known as Sikai Chautari which contains curriculum from Grade 1 to Grade 10. Besides this, many universities and colleges have now started running online classes. These have become most important methods in this pandemic situation to enhance better education and better learning.
The emerging practice of using technology in education has been promoting E-learning (online learning) among Nepali students. Although some educational institutions have started E-learning (online classes) it remains as a major challenge to involve all student`s active participation and involvement.
Nepal belongs to the least developed countries with high poverty rate. Despite the progress Nepal has made in recent years, poverty still remains one of the major problems. About 25.2 percent people in Nepal live below poverty line. People of Nepal have average income and the first most problem will be in access of digital devices. Not all family have capability to buy digital devices as well as this pandemic has raised financial issues among most of the family members.
The World Bank projects about 31.2 percent of our population face significant risks of falling into extreme poverty, primarily because of reduced remittances, foreign earnings of potential migrants, job losses in the informal sector, and rising prices for essential commodities as a result of COVID-19. Many of them have already lost their job and faced huge losses in business, while many families are deprived of foods and essential materials. So, it is clear that family facing these problems will have food, shelter and essential materials as their priority needs rather than spending their money in learning through E-courses or buying digital devices. Spending money to buy internet access or mobile data is a big challenge for the people suffering from financial issues.
Ayush Ojha, 14, a resident of Rupa -2, Kaski is a nine class student who has access to Smartphone but doesn’t have internet service at his home. His parent cannot afford an internet connection that costs their month’s salary. So, it is difficult for him to take classes everyday although he used to go his friends home to attend classes.
Though E-learning is considered as cost-effective, Government of Nepal lags well behind in providing free internet services in all parts of Nepal. Even the Internet connections provided by Internet service providers are unreliable and poor and in some places cell phone connection is still a problem. Also providing internet connectivity to all people is a very expensive investment for the governments of developing countries like Nepal who has others major issues to deal with.
In this case E-learning will not be suitable for those who do not have regular access to internet facility or electronic devices. Nearly more than 80% people of Nepal lives in rural part of Nepal. As many parts of Nepal are covered with hills and mountains and due to difficult geographical situation of Nepal, people living in rural part of Nepal face many problems because of unmanaged roads, bridges, rivers, inadequate supply of electricity, absence of internet availability, unavailability of phone towers and all these factors are the barriers for conducting effective E-learning in those area of Nepal.
Some universities have started online courses in this COVID-19situation but it seems to be effective in urban part of Nepal only. Most of the teachers and students from the rural part of Nepal may not be familiar of using technology on the right way as they are less exposed to technological advancements. In this part teachers with traditional teaching experiences should be capable of using all the new technological means and devices like using webcams, the email, videos, audios, slides, Microsoft packages, and also should have good typing skills and capable of dealing with many numbers of students at one time. It would become a great challenge in introducing E-learning courses out in rural areas simply because essential requirements wouldn’t meet.
This educational disruption will continue to have substantial effects, extending beyond education. The disruption also concerns health and psychosocial issues, since educational institutions also serve as platforms for prevention, diagnosis, and counselling. Similarly unavailability to attend the regular online classes has created numerous psychological problems to both students and teachers. The one with better economic status will have proper access to internet and electronic devices whereas the one with lower economic status lacks proper and adequate access to internet & electronic devices that directly affects their participation in e-learning courses. COVID-19 has shown that education institution closures represent an increased risk of mental problem, such as stress, anxiety and depression as well as types of abuse, such as domestic violence, early and forced marriages.
Sumitra Aryal, 22 a resident of Bhimad-4, Tanahun an undergraduate students of public health says she has two siblings and only one Smartphone available at her home. Her sisters also have online classes at the same time so she feels difficulty in taking online classes most of the time and misses several classes and assignments. Thus, the three take turns participating in the class.
The Ministry of Education, Science, and Technology have been less active in dealing educational problems in this pandemic and have been criticized heavily. The halted exams of SEE, Grade 11 & 12 and almost all levels have draw huge attention and dragged huge criticism to the government on inactiveness to deal with the issue. With high criticism from the public, the government has initiated several programs like TV shows, mobilizing private educational sector as well as providing effective notice to the students.
Similarly it also has given permission to conduct online classes at different levels to both private and public institutions. A number of schools and colleges, mostly privately-run attempted to switch to online classes in late Jestha. However, many of them halted their efforts after the government instructed schools in Shrawn, 2077not to enroll new students amid the pandemic and end online classes. However when it ordered to end such programs it draw huge backlash of government and showed its inefficiency to decide a couple of things. This has raised serious questions on government plan to make education technology friendly.
The “School Re-operation Action Plan-2077”, have given power to the local authority to decide whether to open schools in the levels or not. In view of Educationist Dr Vidyanath Koirala, areas vulnerable and less-vulnerable to the Covid-19 has to be identified first and schools remaining in the second category could be opened after going through Covid-19 test of teachers.However, there stills remains the hegemony of the state government influence in operation of schools and colleges in less infected areas.
For example, there are no active cases of Covid-19 in Jumla so, the local government plans to reopen the schools following proper guidelines and protocols but the state government did not gave permission to reopen those schools rather suggest to rung their academic courses through online classes . But it seems to be challenging as Majority (2/3) of students doesn’t have any access to radio, TV, internet connection and modern digital devices. The mayor of Jumla, Mrs. Kantika Sejuwal in a recent interview stress concerns over the remaining 2 and half months of academic year in upper Himalayan belt of the district where the academic year loss problem is inevitable.
The council of ministers meeting on Ashoj 1 have passed down an “Education Related Emergency Action Plan-2077”,that will ensure students proper education, evaluation , teacher-student relation building, self learning , alternative learning process with most of the priority given to e- learning. It also has made arrangements to provide free internet to students and schools from Ashoj, 2077 to facilitate e-learning. Students, schools and teachers can access to free internet service by filling a simple KYC form and can attend classes on Google meet, Zoom and Ms-team for free. A large section of students who have to purchase data packages to attend their classes have been relieved of the problems of internet facility. This plan of action plan has raised concerns that schools and university new normal will be a long time soon.
However, there are still problems which government need to act properly to reduce all those barriers that are prevalent in this sector. As countries began to see a “flattening of the curve” of new cases of COVID-19 among their population, many governments began to loosen restrictions in an effort to stabilize their economies, including through the reopening of schools, while others have been more cautious and maintained closures, fearing a “second wave”.some countries have opened schools and colleges, only to close them again after a resurgence of the virus. As of today, roughly 40 UK Universities have reported COVID-19 Cases, with thousands of students self-isolating.
The logistical challenges related to ensuring distance educational continuity during prolonged closures are substantial. Protracted closures threaten the implementation of the academic calendar and of examinations, and make it next-to-impossible to put remedial programmes in place. Assessing distance learning further complicated the picture, as noted above. Finally, there are risks to the well-being and protection of students and there is a need to address the well-being and health concerns of teachers, and to provide them with remote support, including through teacher training on online pedagogy. Successive closures and reopening are likely to continue, as the virus continues to circulate globally. Several countries are planning to implement a “hybrid” or blended model of education provision.
The shock of the COVID-19 crisis on education has been unprecedented. It has set the clock back on the attainment of education goals, and disproportionately affected the poorer and most vulnerable. And yet, the education community has proved resilient, laying groundwork for the rebound. There remains a risk of a downward spiral, in a negative feedback loop of learning loss and exclusion. Yet every negative spiral of aggravating socio-economic circumstances suggests its reverse image of a positive spiral, one which would lead to the future of education we want: one of inclusive change in education delivery system i.e.E-learning. Observing the present scenario, practice of E- learning would be the best option to mitigate some impacts on educational sector caused by this pandemic.
Thus, it is the responsibility of governments to stay true to principles and conduct reforms, so that, not only will the children and youth regain their promised future, but all education stakeholders find their role in making it happen.
The writer is an undergraduate student of Public Health at Cist College, Kathmandu.
Published on 1 October 2020
Dialogue on Narayani River Conservation in Nawalpur
Nawalpur, 23 September (2022) - Stakeholders have emphasized conservation of the Narayani River tha…
Covid-19 management: A herculean task for Nepal
"We are in dire need of a comprehensive legislation to deal with pandemics"
'National unity' led Qatar's resilience against the blockade imposed by neighbors - Yousuf Bin Mohamed, Qatar's Ambassador to Nepal [Interview]
COVID-19's impact on Dalit community in Nepal
Mediation in rape cases: Utterly unacceptable
Education during COVID-19: Is E-learning a good alternative?